Posted by: Schuyler R. Thorpe | June 27, 2011

FEMA: “EF-4 Tornado? Insufficient Damage To Claim Recovery Money.”

(So your house gets blown away in an EF-4 tornado and FEMA says that there’s “insufficient damage” to warrant any approval of federal aid…?


Citing ‘insufficient damage,’ FEMA rejects aid claims on homes battered by tornado

When that tornado ripped through Alabama in late April, it turned Jonathan Stewart’s house into a pile of rubble.

Soon afterward, an inspector from the Federal Emergency Management Agency came to the house–or what remained of it, anyway–in Pleasant Grove, near Birmingham, where Stewart, his wife Lisa, and their two kids live. The inspector took pictures and notes, as part of a process to allow the Stewarts to get help from the disaster relief agency.

But a few days later, Stewart received a letter from FEMA. “Based on your FEMA inspection, we have determined that the disaster has not caused your home to be unsafe to live in,” the letter said. It informed Stewart that he didn’t qualify for a FEMA grant–in part because his home had suffered “insufficient damage.”

“Lisa and I looked at the letter and laughed,” Stewart told the Birmingham News.

The Stewarts weren’t alone. The home of Lashunta Tabb, who lives in a town nearby, had half its roof blown off and three damaged walls, and its siding stripped off. She said it’s uninhabitable. But FEMA also turned her claim down, citing the same reason: insufficient damage.

“Although the disaster may have caused some minor damage, it is reasonable to expect you or your landlord to make these repairs,” the letters received by both Tabb and the Stewarts said. “At this time you are not eligible for FEMA housing assistance.”

FEMA has said that people who think they were incorrectly turned down for aid should appeal the decision. But it said that less than 1 percent of those declared ineligible had done so.

In fact, Stewart said he has since found out that his insurance coverage will replace his house, meaning he’s ineligible for a FEMA grant anyway. But he added that he wonders how many other people there who might qualify for FEMA funds, but received that same “insufficient damage” finding, and abandoned the process in frustration.

FEMA has issued similarly head-scratching “insufficient damage” findings in response to several other recent disasters, including Hurricane Katrina in 2005, and Hurricane Dolly, which ravaged Texas in 2008. A pending lawsuit charges that the agency improperly denied aid to thousands of poor farm workers whose homes were badly damaged by Dolly.

But some say FEMA is in a no-win position. After the 2004 Florida hurricanes and Hurricane Katrina, the agency came in for heavy criticism from both Congress’s General Accounting Office and detractors in the press, for paying out money to people who shouldn’t have qualified.

“In Katrina they lost so much money because they were not careful about payout,” Clare Rubin, a disaster management consultant, told the News. “The GAO hit them hard.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


Gypsy Nerds

Gett'n our travel on!

Jen's Writers Blog

A place for the imagination!

Dreams of Dark Angels

The blog of fantasy writer Storm Constantine

Passion with a Dark and Dangerous Twist

A site for romance and thriller author, Cassandre Dayne

H.J. Bradley

The world of an aspiring indie author.

Q13 FOX News

Seattle and Western Washington's source for breaking news, weather, and sports. Home of Washington’s Most Wanted and the Seattle Seahawks.


Author Tim Baker shares his thoughts, hopes and dreams. (mostly his thoughts)

Kait Nolan

Smart, sassy, small town Southern romance that makes you feel like home

Guild Of Dreams

Build Your World and They Will Come

Trent Lewin

Fiction, and other made-up stories

Wildhorse33's Blog

freeing the creative spirit

Here's To Us

Nerdiness Encouraged

%d bloggers like this: